Charcoal gives you something gas cannot quite copy: direct control over the fire itself. The best charcoal grill depends on whether you want a classic kettle, a more durable grill-and-smoker platform, or kamado-style heat retention.
Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Best overall kettle: Weber Master-Touch 22
Best value classic: Weber Original Kettle Premium 22
Best grill-and-smoker upgrade: PK300
Best kamado value: Char-Griller AKORN
The Master-Touch keeps the simplicity that makes a kettle grill so useful, while adding a lid holder, hinged cooking grate, warming rack and built-in thermometer. Weber lists a 22-inch diameter, 363 square inches of primary cooking area and 443 square inches total.
Best for: people who want to grill steaks and burgers, learn two-zone cooking and occasionally smoke ribs or pork without owning a separate smoker.
The Original Kettle Premium is hard to beat if you want the classic charcoal experience without paying for extras you may not use. Its 22-inch grate provides 363 square inches of cooking area, and the ash-catching system makes cleanup much easier than basic open-pan charcoal grills.
Best for: first-time charcoal buyers and experienced grillers who value simple equipment that can do a lot.
The PK300 uses a cast-aluminum capsule and four-point venting rather than the round steel bowl of a kettle. The shape is especially useful for direct and indirect zones, and the aluminum construction is resistant to rust.
Best for: charcoal cooks who want a durable long-term grill that is also very comfortable running low-and-slow.
Watch out for: it is substantially more expensive than a standard kettle.
The AKORN is a steel insulated kamado rather than a heavy ceramic cooker. Char-Griller lists 310 square inches of primary cooking area, 450 square inches total and a temperature range from about 200°F to 700°F.
Best for: cooks attracted to kamado heat retention and fuel efficiency but who do not want the price or weight of a large ceramic model.
A kettle is still our default recommendation for most people because it is inexpensive, responsive to vent changes and supported by a huge accessory ecosystem. Pick the PK300 if durability and two-zone smoking matter most. Pick the AKORN if you specifically want the insulated kamado style.
For a direct fuel comparison, read Gas vs Charcoal Grill: Which Is Better for You?